Gays With Kids expert James Guay tackles another tough question from our community, this time contributed anonymously:

"I am reaching out in this way because I am too embarrassed and ashamed to discuss this with family or friends. Before we met, my husband and I both wanted children. I knew it would be difficult, which is why I did not opt to become a single dad. We dated, we married, and we got a child through the foster system. As of last June, he became ours.

My husband and I both work typical 9 to 5 jobs. He spends a lot of time away from home, like 3 to 5 evenings a week. I feel like a single parent. My husband has told me many times how I "forced" him to get a child. And several days ago my husband told me he "tried to love" our son (meaning he does not love him), and that our son had sucked "all the joy from our lives."

While I do not want a separation or divorce, I do want a healthy environment for my son even more. The only solution I see at this point is for my son and I to move out and begin fresh, leaving my husband to pursue his life in a carefree, childless, single guy manner. (We would leave the home because my husband bought the house we live in a couple of years before we met and he regularly reminds me "this is my house.")

As I type this, I am writing as dispassionately as possible, yet when I read my own words, it seems so much worse than in my head. Any advice you have to offer is appreciated.”

James Guay responds and lists four different options for this gay dad to consider:

  1. Consider couples or family therapy:

It's about doing due diligence and trying that one last ditch effort to resolve the situation.

  1. Single parenting has its benefits

Sometimes people find that being a single parent is better than co-parenting when your partner isn't as involved as you want them to be. They can potentially give you a few hours off, a weekend off, and you can really show up for your child in ways you might not be able to under the current circumstances.

  1. What have you learned that you can apply moving forward?

It's important to recognize if there is anything different you could've done. Were there signs along the way that your partner wasn't willing to be the 24 / 7 parent that you needed them to be.

  1. You are not alone!

There are so many single parents that did not sign up to be that, and that do perfectly well. They are happy, and healthy; busy, but are wonderful parents and find it incredibly rewarding.

James Guay is an LGBTQ-positive licensed marriage and family therapist. Find out more about James on his website, Facebook, Twitter or YouTube channel.


Have a question you want one of our experts to answer as part of our Ask An Expert advice column? Send an email with your question to with “Ask An Expert” in the subject line.

Keep reading... Show less
Become a Gay Dad

Do Gay Men REALLY Make Good Dads?

Family therapist James Guay helps a gay couple answer the question: Can gay men really be good parents?

Jake Aschmutat and Jim O'Malley are interested in having kids soon. But as they've begun to explore their prospects, they've faced some tough questions from family members: will the kids really be all right being raised by day dads?

Keep reading... Show less

Did your family vote for Trump? Feeling betrayed, depressed, hurt, angry, or scared? Finding it difficult to imagine being with your family of origin during the holidays?
Keep reading... Show less

WatcIt is estimated that somewhere between 10% and 25% of new dads experience Paternal Postpartum Depression (PPD) during their child's first year.

What is Paternal Postpartum Depression (PPD)? How can you recognize it? And, most importantly, what can be done about it?

James Guay, our resident gay-positive LMFT, explains what it is, how to recognize it and, most importantly, treatment options. For more information, check out and

Watch more videos in James Guay's Living More Fully series here.

Full transcript below:

"Paternal postpartum depression not only affects straight dads, but it also affects gay, bisexual and pansexual dads, too. It’s very, very common, regardless of gender, sexual orientation, age, race, ability; it’s much more common than people imagine.

There are some estimates of anywhere between 10% and 25% of new dads become depressed within the first year of becoming a father.

So what are the symptoms of postpartum depression or anxiety? It’s also called peripartum or postnatal depression.

Especially for guys, there can be an increased amount of anger, irritability or outbursts, those kinds of things. Because often men are socialized to think that being depressed is being weak, and it’s not – it’s just part of the human experience.

There can be other symptoms like:

Keep reading... Show less

Welcome to the first installment of our new video series for gay dads: Ask the Therapist. Our resident LGBTQ-positive licensed marriage and family therapist James Guay,, responds directly to questions from our community. This first question was submitted by Stephen from Colorado via Facebook: "My son wants a mommy. How should I respond?"

Keep reading... Show less

How can gay dads find a positive and healthy religious environment for their family? Here are four questions to consider about a potential religious institution:

Keep reading... Show less

How do gay men sustain the passion and desire in their long-term relationships, especially when they're dads? Here are three tips to help rekindle the spark shared by James Guay, our resident gay-positive LMFT.

Keep reading... Show less

James Guay, our resident gay-positive LMFT, shares three tips for talking to your kids about homophobia and prejudices of all kind so they are respectful and welcoming of those who are different.

Keep reading... Show less

Fatherhood, the gay way

Get the latest from Gays With Kids delivered to your inbox!

Follow Gays With Kids

Powered by RebelMouse