Surrogacy for Gay Men

The Ongoing Gay Legacy of CT Fertility

Roughly 90% of the patients at CT Fertility are gay men. And that's not by accident.

**CT Fertility is now closed. Message from CT Fertility: "Thank you for entrusting your care to us for the past 25 years. We wish each and every one of you all the best."**

Here's a shocker: it turns out us gay dudes don't know diddly about the female reproductive system. That will change pretty rapidly, though, if you step foot inside the offices of CT Fertility.

"Gay male couples tend to have no clue about pregnancy when they first walk in," laughed Medical Director at CT Fertility, Dr. Melvin H. Thornton II. "I'm sometimes accused of giving out too much information, but I'd rather give too much than too little."

The bulk of his patients are gay, which means Dr. Thornton, who has over 22 years of experience in the fertility world, has become something of a part-time professor in addition to a medical professional as he shepherds gay men and couples through the process of creating embryos.


"These guys just want a family, that's what they know," said Linda Vignapiano, Director of Clinical Operations for the East Coast for CT Fertility's parent company, IntegraMed. "So they have no idea what PGS is, for example, so we try to teach them."

"Really? That's crazy," I laughed along with her.

"That's Preimplantation Genetic Screening," Linda clarified a moment later, likely sensing, like most gay men, I had no idea what she was talking about. (Hey, admit it, you didn't know either.)

Herein lies how CT Fertility is setting itself apart. Particularly for an industry whose entire goal is to help make dreams of parenthood come true, the process can often feel incredibly sterile and impersonal. But at CT Fertility—whether you like it or not—you're going to be kept in the loop.

***

Roughly 90% of the patients at CT Fertility are gay men, and this is not by accident. Over 25 years ago, a man by the name of Dr. Michael Doyle founded CT Fertility with the explicit goal of helping LGBTQ people start their families.

"He was really a trailblazer," Linda said, noting Dr. Doyle worked hard to establish CT Fertility as an early leader in the LGBTQ community.

Two years ago, Dr. Doyle left clinical practice and was replaced by a man who spent 15 years as the Medical Director of the Columbia University IVF program, and nine years as Director of their donor egg program—Dr. Melvin H. Thornton II.

Dr. Melvin H. Thornton II

It's an intimidating name. But you need just a couple of minutes with Dr. Thornton to understand why Dr. Thornton fits in comfortably at CT Fertility.

"I started my practice initially in Southern California, where everyone talks to everybody," said Dr. Thornton. When he moved to New York to begin working at Columbia, he realized something about East Coasters: "Nobody talks," he said.

If you walk into Dr. Thornton's office, however, not talking is not an option.

"The first thing I like to do in a consultation is ask questions that sometimes surprise them," said Dr. Thornton. "I ask how they met, or how long they've been together. I ask how their engagement was."

Next, Dr. Thornton does something else you might not expect from a man with a roman numeral after his name: mental visualization exercises. Close your eyes and look into your future 10 years, he'll say. Imagine yourself in Central Park on a nice summer day.

How many children do you see with you?

"The number is usually controversial," he says. "One partner says two, the other says three. Then they'll look at each other, and think: wait, what do you mean? I want them to help them have the family they really want, but they need to get on the same page."

But he also wants to make sure intended parents never get too bogged down in the details. "This whole process is about family," he said. "It's important to never lose sight of that."

***

Both Linda and Dr. Thornton, with their combined experience of nearly 50 years in the fertility industry, say working with gay men is a pleasure. Working for straight couples and women can be more difficult, they say, since they are often treating infertility, or attempting to conceive at an advanced age, meaning success is less of a given.

"When gay couples come in, you typically have a donor egg, healthy sperm and a gestational carrier with a proven uterus," said Dr. Thornton. "You can pretty much be confident they will have the family they're looking for."

"I had infertility myself," said Linda Vignapiano. "I know what it's like. So working with gay couples—everybody is just happy and excited."

Linda Vignapiano

The success rate for gay men may be much higher, but that doesn't mean the process is any simpler. In fact, in many ways, it can be much more complicated.

"In the old days, I just had a man and a woman and I knew what I was doing," Linda said. "Now? I have two men, an egg donor, a surrogate, and a surrogacy agency I interact with. It's a party!"

What this means for CT Fertility, specifically, is that the clinic has learned to adapt its business practices to anticipate and accommodate the different needs of their LGBTQ intended parents.

For instance, at other fertility clinics with less experience working with gay men, you may end up with one coordinator for the intended parents, another for the surrogate, and yet another for the donor. At CT Fertility, Linda says continuity is key: intended parents, donors and surrogates all have the same coordinator.

"At some of the larger IVF clinics, we've been told by patients that it can feel like a conveyor belt—they never get the same person twice," she explained. At CT Fertility, "you're not going to get a 'doc of the day,'" she continued, meaning if you are a patient of Dr. Thornton's to start with, you will stay that way throughout the entire process, from your initial consult to your surrogate's transfer. "That feels good to our patients."

***

While no official numbers exist, many fertility clinics have reported a rise in the number of gay couples seeking to start their families via surrogacy in recent years, thanks in large part to marriage equality and increased societal acceptance of LGBTQ parents.

"The biggest thing I've seen change for gay men in recent years is the simple reality that they can have a child this way," said Dr. Thornton. "You'd be surprised, I've talked to lots of gay men who didn't know this was available to them."

But what work still needs to be done in order to make surrogacy more widely available to gay men?

First and foremost: the price tag remains a major sticking point. Though some financial assistance programs like the one offered by Men Having Babies has helped put surrogacy within reach of more gay men and couples, the option will remain inaccessible until it becomes more affordable.

Dr. Thornton says he's encouraged that a few larger companies, like Deutsche Bank and Google, have begun to provide fertility services for gay couples. "But everyone should have a right to fertility," he said. "If you're a gay man who works for a company that has IVF coverage, you should be allowed to create embryos."

And while attitudes around gay men and surrogacy are improving by the years, some stigmas continue to linger.

"Somebody needs to educate the FDA," Linda said, explaining that, just like with blood donation, gay men are considered "high risk" sperm donors by the government and are thus automatically barred from being considered a "qualified" tissue donor. In practice, all this means is the surrogate needs to sign a waiver acknowledging the "increased risk."

"But it just really sticks in my craw," Linda said. "It's not even like they are 'donating' anything—these are their babies!"

Still, Dr. Thornton says we are lucky to have the option of surrogacy at all in the United States. "In certain countries, you can't even talk about surrogacy," he said. "So it's great to have the reproduction freedom we have, I just wish it was more widely available to everyone."

With states like New York and New Jersey looking to legalize surrogacy this year, and advocates pushing more businesses to cover fertility treatments for LGBTQ couples, it's clear the option is likely to soon become available to more gay men.

And when that happens, the staff at CT Fertility will be there, eagerly waiting to educate you.

Show Comments ()
Surrogacy for Gay Men

'Men Having Babies' to Make Case for New York Surrogacy Reform

Come this Friday to hear how Men Having Babies and other advocates plan to pass surrogacy reform in NY

Three MHB members lobbying in Albany, with Senator Brad Hoylman, who led the passage of the Senate version of the bill

Since it's very first meeting in the form of a 2005 support group for biological gay dads and dads-to-be, Men Having Babies (MHB) has been advocating and educating folks on surrogacy. This has taken place in the form of many elements including conferences for those considering surrogacy, their Gay Parenting Assistance Program which helps fund many gay men undertaking the expensive surrogacy journey to fatherhood, and their extensive directory and review system on surrogacy agencies and clinics.

MHB has recently moved further to make their conferences a meeting place for committed surrogacy and gay parenting supporters, including parents, surrogates, researchers, professionals, and policymakers by creating the Advocacy and Research Forum for Surrogacy and LGBT Parenting (ARF). The program provides opportunities for formal and facilitated discussions about topics and developments relevant to parenting through surrogacy and / or by LGBT parents.

Now, in the aftermath of the stalled Child Parent Security Act (the CPSA bill), which was set to reverse the ban on compensated surrogacy in the state of New York, Men Having Babies have gone a step further. As part of the ARF initiative, this Friday November 8 in New York City, Men Having Babies welcomes folks to join them at an open to the public event: The Case for NY Surrogacy Reform.

Keep reading... Show less
Surrogacy for Gay Men

A Dream Becomes Reality, After a Men Having Babies Conference

New Yorkers David and Brian said their dreams of fatherhood crystalized only after receiving a "ton of information" at a Men Having Babies conference.

New Yorkers David F.M. Vaughn 39, and Brian Becker, 37, are new dads. Over the past three months, the two most important things they've learned as fathers is "patience, and how to swaddle LIKE A CHAMP!" David and Brian chose surrogacy as their path to fatherhood, but making that decision was one of the more difficult parts of their journey. Brian's siblings are adopted, and while they still want to make adoption part of their family journey, certain opportunities arose that made their surrogacy decision easier. Brian's sister enthusiastically offered to be their gestational surrogate, and they discovered more about the process with the help of Men Having Babies (MHB).

But let's jump back to the beginning of their story.

Keep reading... Show less
Surrogacy for Gay Men

Gay Surrogacy in the U.S. for International Dads

Kristin Marsoli of Circle Surrogacy breaks down the process of surrogacy for gay men outside of the United States

Written by Circle Surrogacy & Egg Donation, who has been helping international gay men become dads for over two decades.

Becoming a gay dad through a surrogacy agency in the U.S. – when you live outside of the United States – can feel overwhelming. You may have questions such as: Why should I come all the way to the US for surrogacy? What do I need to know as an international intended parent? How do I get my baby home?

We spoke with Circle Surrogacy & Egg Donation who has been working with international gay parents for over two decades. Circle Surrogacy was founded by a gay dad and lawyer, and is the most successful surrogacy agency with a full legal team on staff who are experts working with international parents.

Keep reading... Show less
Gay Dad Family Stories

David and Ben Met on the Dance Floor — and Are Now Grooving Their Way Through Fatherhood

David and Ben, who became fathers with the help of Northwest Surrogacy Center, live in Melbourne with their daughter, Maia.

In 2003, while both studying at Reading University in the UK, Ben Suter and David Cocks met after locking eyes on the dance floor and then being introduced by a mutual friend. Ben, a meteorologist and Operations Manager, and David, an Assistant Principal, have been together ever since. They moved to Australia together in 2010, seeking a different life, and an overall better work-life balance. The chose Cairns in Queensland as their new home, between the Great Barrier Reef and the tropical rainforest, "taking life a bit easier," said David. The couple were also married in June 2016, back home in England.

While David always wanted kids, Ben took a little convincing. So they started their parenting journey with a dog, Titan, who quickly became like their first born. From there, Ben came around rather quickly.

Keep reading... Show less
Personal Essays by Gay Dads

Single Gay Dad and the City

When Kyle decided to take his four kids, ages 6-11, to New York City on vacation, his friends thought he was crazy.

"You're crazy, Kyle."

"You can't be serious? A single dad taking four kids to the Big Apple? Think again."

"That's bold. There's no way I'd do that."

Those were a few of the responses I heard from my friends as I told them I was thinking of booking a trip to New York City with four kids, ages 11-6. My children's fall vacation from school was approaching and I wanted to get out of the house and explore. Was the Big Apple too much of an adventure?

Keep reading... Show less
News

National's Pitcher Cites Wife's Two Moms as Reason for Declining White House Invite

"I think that's an important part of allyship," Doolittle said of his wife's two moms.

Sean Doolittle, pitcher for the Washington Nationals, declined an invitation to the White House after his team won the World Series this year. In an interview with the Washington Post, he listed his numerous reasons for staying home — and a main consideration, he revealed, was his wife's two moms.

"I want to show support for them. I think that's an important part of allyship, and I don't want to turn my back on them," Doolittle said during the interview.

Trump's treatment of a minority groups, generally, factored into his decision as well. "I have a brother-in-law who has autism, and [Trump] is a guy that mocked a disabled reporter. How would I explain that to him that I hung out with somebody who mocked the way that he talked or the way that he moves his hands? I can't get past that stuff."

Doolitttle clarified that his decision had little to do with policy disagreements with the White House. "There's a lot of things, policies that I disagree with, but at the end of the day, it has more to do with the divisive rhetoric and the enabling of conspiracy theories and widening the divide in this country. My wife and I stand for inclusion and acceptance, and we've done work with refugees, people that come from, you know, the 'shithole countries.'"

He concluded by saying he respected his teammates decision to attend the White house ceremony. "I want people to know that I put thought into this, and at the end of the day, I just can't go."

Read more of the Washington Post interview here.

News

New York Will Fight 'Repugnant' Trump Rule on Adoption, Says Cuomo

Governor Andrew Cuomo of New York promises legal action of the Trump administration moves ahead with plans to allow discrimination against LGBTQ adoptive and foster parents

Last week, the Trump administration announced plans to allow adoption and foster care agencies to discriminate against prospective LGBTQ parents — but he may face a legal fight from (former) hometown. In a tweet, Governor Andrew Cuomo of New York said the proposed move "isn't just discriminatory and repugnant to our values,— it's also heartless and dumb as it would deny countless children a loving family and a safe place to call home." If the proposal moves forward, he continued. "we'll take legal action to stop it.

Governor Cuomo's office followed up the tweet with a lengthier statement posted to their website:

Once again the Trump administration is attacking the hard-earned rights and protections of the LGBTQ community, this time proposing a new measure that would give foster care and adoption agencies license to discriminate based on sexual orientation or gender identity.

Trump's proposal isn't just discriminatory and repugnant to our values — it's also heartless and dumb as it would deny countless children a loving family and a safe place to call home. If he moves forward with this rule, we'll take legal action to stop it.

No matter what happens in Washington, New York State is and will continue to be a beacon of equality in this country. Our Human Rights Law and adoption regulations expressly prohibit discrimination against the LGBTQ community, including when it comes to adoption. I encourage any LGBTQ New Yorker who feels they are a victim of this discrimination to contact the State Division of Human Rights for assistance.

Our message to the Trump administration is simple: there is no place for hate in New York or in our nation, and we will not allow this noxious proposal to stop LGBTQ New Yorkers from becoming parents or providing care to children in need.

Fatherhood, the gay way

Get the latest from Gays With Kids delivered to your inbox!

Follow Gays With Kids

Powered by RebelMouse