Thanksgiving Dinner Dessert Recipes From Gay Dad Erik

Some of my fondest memories growing up were the smells coming from my grandmother's kitchen. We were always so excited after Halloween because we knew that she was going to be baking in her kitchen from Thanksgiving until New Years. I have been replicating some of those very recipes for years now because just one whiff transports me back in time in just a matter of seconds.

I remember as a little boy the happiness I felt for the first pie or cookie she took out of the oven. The pure anticipation was almost too much to handle!
All of those traditions I think are so important to pass down to my children. I want to see their excitement when they come home from school and smell pralines as they walk up the drive way. I want to hear their joy when I ask them to help me roll out the cookie dough to make Christmas stars. To me, traditions are an integral part of growing up and I feel it is my responsibility to keep the magic alive!
I thought it being almost Thanksgiving, I would share three of my most precious dessert recipes that are a huge hit with my loved ones. I sincerely hope you enjoy them as they are a piece of my family as a gift to your family.
Southern Pecan Pralines
Pralines are a staple in the south. The way they crumble and melt in your mouth ensures them to be a unique addition to any dessert spread. There are many different variations and over the years I have learned and perfected my very own.

Pralines can also be pretty tricky. There is a certain technique to ensure these treats are perfect. Not letting the mixture cool long enough makes them sticky and not the consistency that you are looking for.

Making sure you have all the necessary utensils are very important.

A few of them are:

wooden spoon – My wooden spoon I have had for years and it is key to scraping the bottoms of pots so you do not damage the surfaces. When using your wooden spoon make sure you designate either sweet or savory dishes for its lifespan because certain foods seep into the wood.

2-quart saucepan – It is important that it is non-stick, light-weight and easy to handle.

Candy thermometer – When making anything like pralines, fudge and caramel, a candy thermometer is critical. It gives you a fail-proof reading, letting you know when exactly your treats are ready for the next step.

Silpat – A silpat is a rubber mat that is used instead of parchment or wax paper. They are reusable and much more efficient and are much cheaper over time than the others. My silpat has come in handy so many times!


1 1/2 cups white granulated sugar

1 1/2 cups light brown sugar

1/8 teaspoon salt

2 tablespoons light corn syrup (helps prevent crystallization of mixture)

1 cup sour cream

2 tablespoons butter

1 teaspoon vanilla extract (high quality)

1/2 teaspoon baking soda

1 ½ to 2 cups of chopped pecans (depending on how much you like them)

Getting started:

Butter the sides of sauce pan.

Place sugars, salt, corn syrup, sour cream and

butter into pan.

Over medium heat stir consistently with wooden spoon until mixture comes to a boil. Add your candy thermometer to the side of your pan and continue to cook, until your reach exactly 240 degrees, stirring occasionally.

Cooling the mixture:

You can either do "cold water test" which is where you take some of the mixture onto a spoon and dip it into cold water, it should flatten down when you press it.

Or you can let the mixture cool for about 5-6 minutes.

Once it’s cooled, add vanilla and nuts.


Beat for 2 minutes with your wooden spoon until mixture loses its glossy shine.

When the mixture is no longer shiny – VERY QUICKLY – drop spoonfuls down on your silpat. This is a very fast process and the quicker you get the mixture out of the pot and onto your mat, the better your pralines will look.

Cooling pralines:

It takes just a few minutes for them to cool. The smell of your kitchen right now is the stuff traditions are made from!

Don't worry if your pralines did not come out pretty. It's okay! It takes many times to perfect your technique. Practice makes perfect! If they came out beautiful, congratulations! I'm sure they will disappear in a matter or hours!

Yields: around 18

Meyer Lemon Star Cookies

I have had Meyer lemon trees for years. A Meyer lemon is a hybrid of an orange and a lemon. They are sour with just a hint of sweet and they add just the right amount of tartness to a variety of dishes whether savory or sweet.

I have found that with my cookies, the lemon icing really serves the punch I am looking for.

It is not at all mandatory to have Meyer lemons for this recipe. You actually could omit lemons all together if you aren't a lemon fan. The icing is the only component that has lemon juice.

The cookie itself holds up beautifully for up to a week. They are soft and make the best holiday cookies.

Getting started, make sure you have your necessary utensils:

2 silpats

mixer (either Kitchen Aid or hand mixer)

large mixing bowl

plastic wrap

2 cookie sheets

Ingredients for cookies:

1 1/2 cups butter softened

2 cups of white sugar

4 eggs

1 teaspoon vanilla extract (good quality)

5 cups of all purpose flour

2 teaspoons baking powder

1 teaspoon plus 1/8 teaspoon of salt

Ingredients for icing:

1 Meyer lemon

1 box of confectioners sugar

Yellow food coloring

In a large bowl or kitchen aid cream together butter and sugar until smooth.

Beat in eggs and vanilla.

Stir in baking powder and salt, and add cup by cup of flour.

Once all is mixed together and dough forms, wrap in plastic wrap and let sit over night in refrigerator.


Preheat oven to 400 degrees (200 degrees Celsius).

Place silpats on cookie sheets.

Roll out dough on floured surface to about 1/2 inch thick.

Cut into stars or desired shapes and place on silpat spaced about 1 inch apart.

Bake about 9 to 11 minutes.

You do NOT want crispy cookies.

Thick and fluffy cookies are ideal.

Let cool for about 3 hours.


Pour confectioners sugar in a bowl

Juice half a lemon.

You want a thick icing, the consistency like you would see on top of cinnamon roll.

If you need more liquid, juice other half of lemon frugally

If you are not using lemon juice, replace with 2 % milk.

Add 3 drops yellow food coloring.

mix together very well until you have a brilliant yellow color.

Spread icing generously and let sit for about 20 minutes.

Love is written in the stars, and so are my star cookies! Enjoy!

Yields: about 32

Chocolate Meringue Pie

Of all the recipes and delicious treats I bake in the kitchen this is the holy grail. My mama used to bake this for Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays but she would often surprise us throughout the year on our birthdays.

The rich and silky, smooth texture that marries with the buttery crust along with the light and airy meringue make this my number one favorite dessert of all time.

Getting started make sure you have all your necessary utensils:

mixing bowl

2-quart sauce pan

Kitchen Aid mixer or hand mixer

wooden spoon

sieve (used for straining chocolate)

cookie sheet

small bowl (for egg whites)

rubber spatula

Ingredients for pie filling:

4 egg yolks

2 cups of white sugar

1/4 cup of all purpose flour

4 tablespoons of cocoa powder

1 (12oz) can of evaperated milk

1 nine inch pie shell- store bought is fine

1/4 cup butter

Quarter teaspoon of salt

1 teaspoon vanilla (good quality)

Ingredients for meringue:

4 egg whites

1 teaspoon cream of tartar

1 tablespoon of sugar

In a sauce pan add cocoa, flour, salt, evaporated milk, vanilla, and butter. Mix together over low-medium heat. Add your egg yolks individually and keep stirring with your wooden spoon until your butter has completely melted. Make sure your flame is not too hot, as the yolks will cook and your custard will be ruined.

Once butter is melted, turn flame off. Place pie shell onto cookie sheet. Pour mixture through sieve into your pie shell leaving all impurities behind, giving you a beautiful silk custard.

Bake at 350 degrees for about 35 minutes.

After baking cycle is complete, test your pie with a slight shake. You want your finished product to jiggle and not ripple. You can also touch the outer edge of your pie with your finger and if it is soft and your finger comes away clean, then your custard is completely baked.

Set aside and begin meringue mixture.

In the mixing bowl add your egg whites, cream of tartar, and sugar-whip on high speed.

Beat mixture until very stiff peaks.

Beat until you get an iridescent  mixture.

Once meringue is completed pour over custard using your rubber spatula. Using upward motion as you dollop gives you the pointed effect that meringue pies are known for.

Place pie bake in over for another 7 to 10 more minutes giving the light brown tint to the meringue.

Let your pie cool for at least 2 to 3 hours.

In this hectic time for our country, some of the most productive things we can do is to find our passions. Teaching our children new things and hearing their laughter as we watch them will not only help you pass the time in an unsettling world but will build and strengthen your own relationships and maybe even start new traditions.

I hope you are able to create new traditions with the ones you care most about.

What are your favorite traditions for Thanksgiving and Christmas? I would love hear them! Comment below and let me know. I hope y'all have a wonderful Thanksgiving!

Try to listen to all of the laughter a little closer this year. You can follow my family's journey on

Instagram @ nolapapa

Posted by Erik Alexander

Erik Alexander is a blogger, writer and creator of He is married to the love of his life, Douglas. Together 14 years, they have 3 beautiful children via adoption. Living in New Orleans, Louisiana, Erik feels that is crucially important that visibility helps normalize what “today’s parent” looks like and created his blog to help light a path for others


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked.

Be a Part of Our Story

Join our continuously growing community of dads, families and industry experts. We’ll provide education, anecdotes and advice for wherever you might be in your journey to fatherhood. Sign up to our newsletter:

Sign up to our newsletter