Change the World

Non-Biological and Non-Adoptive, But Still Dad

Karen Partanen and Julie Gallagher met and started dating in 2001. Soon after, they moved in with each other. In 2007, Gallagher gave birth to their daughter using donor sperm. Several years after that, she gave birth to a son. Partanen wasn’t biologically related to her children, but she fed, bathed, and clothed them. She cooked, cleaned, and looked after them. The kids call her “Mommy.”


Unfortunately, none of this mattered to a Massachusetts Family Court judge when the couple split in 2011. Partanen petitioned for full parental rights after the separation, but she was denied. The reasoning? She had never married Gallagher, wasn’t biologically related to her children, and hadn’t formally adopted them.

Most reasonable people would agree this was an unfair outcome. She was, by any fair definition of the word, a parent. But I’m sure many of us are thinking it, so we might as well address the giant pink elephant in the room: with so many legal protections available to LGBT people these day—namely, marriage and adoption rights—why didn’t Partanen ever take the steps to protect herself?

The short answer is: It’s none of our damn business.

Plenty of straight parents choose to forgo marriage for any number of reasons: some eschew marriage for the patriarchal roots of the institution; others don’t want the government to have a role in validating their relationship; some may simply not care that much, or never get around to tying the knot.

Many LGBT people share these reasons, among others: some simply refuse to be part of an institution that excluded them for so long. Others are irked that advocates prioritized marriage equality over other issues facing our community, like youth homelessness and the lack of national anti-discrimination protections.

The adoption process, too, isn’t always so simple—most family law experts agree that second parent adoption is the single best way for non-biological parents to shore up their rights, even more so than marriage. But it’s also a long, cumbersome process that can cost thousands of dollars. It involves interviews, site visits, and social workers. It can drag on for many months, even years.

It’s not shocking, then, that many LGBT couples—particularly when all is well and good in a relationship—put off completing the adoption process. Perhaps they’re prioritizing limited family resources on food, clothing, and school materials for their children. Maybe they’re miffed by the idea of having to undergo such an intensive and expensive process, all for the right to “adopt” a child they are already busy raising.

That LGBT people must adopt our non-biological children is also a double standard. Second-parent adoption process is without question an incredibly important tool, and one LGBT parents should take advantage of if they are able. But it’s not required, or even recommended, to unmarried fathers in heterosexual relationships, who automatically enjoy a legal presumption of parenthood. Why shouldn’t LGBT people enjoy the same right?

Fortunately, courts around the country are starting to raise this same question.

Just last week, Partanen won her appeal to the Massachusetts Judicial Supreme Court. In a unanimous decision, the court argued that, just as unmarried men in heterosexual relationships benefit from a “presumption of parenthood,” so should people like Partanen, regardless of legal and biological ties. This decision is part of an encouraging trend in courts around the country, which is helping to gradually expand the legal definition of “parenthood” to include non-biological and non-adoptive parents.

It might be hard to understand why some LGBT people—and LGBT parents in particular—choose not to take advantage of marriage and adoption rights we fought so hard to achieve. But true equality means having the option to form our families in whatever way we choose, and in a way equal to our straight counterparts. We’re getting closer, but we’re not there yet.

Show Comments ()
Race

How a White Gay Dad Discusses Racial Issues with his Black Sons

In light of the recent killing of George Floyd by the hands of police in Minneapolis, Joseph Sadusky shares two excerpts from his book that deal directly with issues around raising black sons.

Editor's Note: In light of George Floyd's death, this month, author Joseph Sadusky — who has been sharing excerpts from his book Magic Lessons: Celebratory and Cautionary Tales about Life as a (Single, Gay, Transracially Adoptive) Dad each month —will share two posts that deal directly with issues around raising black sons. This is the first, titled "White," which looks at general questions that come up for a white dad raising black boys. Read previous installments here.

It may be presumptuous for a Caucasian gay man to claim to feel terrified and heartsick at the shooting of Trayvon Martin. But upon hearing the news that day in 2012, this is exactly how I felt.

The horrible truth is that there are many incidents of racial violence toward black males that I could use as starting points for this topic. But the specific case of Trayvon Martin—whose only crime was being a young black male wearing a hoodie, walking in a neighborhood where he had a home—has a particular resonance for me. Whatever the legalities of George Zimmerman using a gun to "stand his ground" if he felt his life was threatened, the simple truth is that he chose—against the direction of law enforcement, whom he contacted for support—to follow an African American male who had every right to be walking those neighborhood streets, however "thug" he might appear.

Keep reading... Show less
Become a Gay Dad

Curious About Covid 19's Impact on Foster Care and Adoption?

Leading industry experts answer questions from queer men about the impact of Covid-19 on the adoption and foster care processes.

Recently, GWK hosted a series of free webinars with leading experts led by industry experts in the fields of adoption and foster care to learn about up-to-date insights on how the coronavirus affects family building. The presentations left lots of room for audience Q&A, to allow participants to get their individual questions answered — there were some common questions raised during each webinar, however, so we've put together a quick video of our experts answering some of the top concerns from queer men interested in pursuing surrogacy.

Our team of experts include:

Have other questions about the impact of the coronavirus on adoption or foster care that you'd like our experts to answer? Be sure to email us at dads@gayswithkids.com.

Keep reading... Show less
Surrogacy for Gay Men

Top 5 Questions About Covid-19's Impact On Surrogacy

Leading industry experts answer questions from queer men about the impact of Covid-19 on the surrogacy process.

Recently, GWK hosted a series of free webinars with leading experts led by industry experts in the field of surrogacy to learn about up-to-date insights on how the coronavirus affects family building. The presentations left lots of room for audience Q&A, to allow participants to get their individual questions answered — there were some common questions raised during each webinar, however, so we've put together a quick video of our experts answering some of the top concerns from queer men interested in pursuing surrogacy.

Our team of experts include:

Have other questions about the impact of the coronavirus on surrogacy that you'd like our experts to answer? Be sure to email us at dads@gayswithkids.com.


Keep reading... Show less
Transracial Families Series

How These Dads Address White Privilege within Their Transracial Family

The "white savior" complex is real, said Andrew and Don, who are raising two Black children.

Editor's Note: This is the first in a series of ongoing posts exploring issues related to transracial families headed by gay, bi and trans men. Interested in being featured as part of the series? Email us at dads@gayswithkids.com

Andrew Kohn, 40, and his husband Donald (Don) Jones, 47, together 13 years, are two white dads raising two Black children in Columbus, Ohio. Do they stick out? Sure. Have they encountered racism? They say they haven't. "I keep waiting for the moment so that I can become my best Julia Sugarbaker," said Andrew. "I think because we're a gay couple with Black kids, we're the other-other and people don't really say things to us. We have never had people touch our kids hair or do something that was inappropriate."

Keep reading... Show less
Children's Books

New LGBTQ-Inclusive Children's Book Asks: What Makes a Family?

A new children's book by Seamus Kirst follows a young girl's journey of emotional discovery after she is asked which of her two dads is her "real dad."

Editor's note: This is a guest post from Seamus Kirst, author of the new LGBTQ-inclusive children's book "Papa, Daddy, Riley."

Throughout my life, I have discovered that reading provides an almost miraculous way of changing the way I think.

There is no medium that better offers insight into the perceptions, feelings and humanity of someone who is different from us. Through reading we become empathetic. Through reading we evolve. I have often emerged from reading a book, and felt like I was changed. In that, even in this digital age, I know I am not alone.

As children, reading shapes how we see the world. The characters, places, and stories we come to love in our books inform us as to what life might offer us as we grow up, and our world begins to expand beyond our own backyards.

Keep reading... Show less
Gay Dad Photo Essays

Interested in Foster Care? These Amazing Dads Have Some Advice

As National Foster Care Month comes to a close, we rounded up some amazing examples of gay men serving as foster care dads, helping provide kids with a bright future.

Every May in the United States, we celebrate National Foster Care Month. With over 437,000 children and youth in foster care, it's our honor to take a look at some of the awesome dads in our community who are opening their hearts and their homes, and providing these kids with a bright future.

Thinking about becoming a foster parent? Check out these resources here, and visit AdoptUSKids.

Meet the Foster Dads!

Keep reading... Show less
Transracial Families Series

This Transracial Family Relies on a 'Support Group' of African American Women

Puerto Rican dads Ferdinand and Manuel are raising a daughter of Jamaican descent — and love to find ways to celebrate their family's diversity

Our second feature in our transracial family series. Read the first one here.

Ferdinand Ortiz, 39, and his husband Manuel Gonzalez, 38, have been together for 7 years. In 2017, they became foster dads when they brought their daughter, Mia Valentina, home from the hospital. She was just three days old at the time. On December 13, 2018, her adoption was finalized.

Mia is of Jamaican and African American heritage, and her dads are both Puerto Rican. When Manuel and Ferdinand began their parenting journey through the foster care system, they received specific training on how to be the parents of a child whose race and culture was different from their own. "We learned that it's important to celebrate our child's culture and surround ourselves with people who can help her be proud of her culture." However, as helpful as this training was, the dads agreed that it would've been beneficial to hear from other transracial families and the type of challenges that they faced.

Keep reading... Show less

Fatherhood, the gay way

Get the latest from Gays With Kids delivered to your inbox!

Follow Gays With Kids

Powered by RebelMouse