Become a Gay Dad

Changing Surrogacy Options for Gay Men Around the Globe (September 2015)

Sam Everingham is a Sydney-based author, researcher and founder of the non-profit consumer organization Families Through Surrogacy, which hosts best-practice conferences each year in the United States, United Kingdom, Europe and Australia. Sam is an authority on the surrogacy landscape internationally, how intended parents try to make their dreams of becoming parents come true, what can go wrong and how to prevent problems. His commentary is regularly sought by regulators and news outlets around the world including CNN, BBC, The Wall Street Journal, The Daily Beast and ABC. Note: This article was originally published in August 2014; below is an updated version from September 2015.

I'm the proud dad of girls Zoe and Ruby, born via gestational surrogacy* in India over four years ago when India was still an option for gay couples.

I never thought that my own desire to be a parent would turn into a significant part of my life's work. But so goes the journey: One couple's struggle becomes the pathway for those who follow. And this is how Families Through Surrogacy (FTS) came about.

My partner and I struck a range of unforeseen obstacles and crises in our path to parenthood in India. As hundreds of intended parents (IPs) around the world started visiting the blog we started in July 2010, it soon become clear that there were thousands of singles and couples who were turning to surrogacy and immersed in tough journeys whether at home or abroad without much support or reliable information.

FTS quickly expanded from a website to hosting multiple social media forums and then best-practice conferences run by volunteer parents who were interested in helping others.

Please bear in mind that for every positive surrogacy story on sites like this, there is a journey which does not go to plan, causing much pain and anguish for all parties. As future and existing gay male parents, it is in our interests to be completely informed about the risks to ourselves as well as those of our children and surrogate mothers.

The recent case of baby Carmen and her gay parents trapped in Thailand because their surrogate changed her mind highlights the need to understand the law (or absence of it) in the country you choose for your surrogacy as well as the importance of 'owning' the process from the outset.

  • Always insist on meeting your gestational surrogate prior to commencing an arrangement. While this can be logistically and linguistically difficult for some, a good agency can arrange Skype-based meetings and translators. If they refuse, don't work with them.
  • Be upfront about being gay. Ensure your surrogate understands you are a gay man or couple before she agrees to work with you.
  • Consider working with a surrogate and egg donor who are open to maintaining contact post birth. While this may not be important to you, it may be to your child(ren) as they grow up. For local cultural reasons, egg donors from India are always anonymous, while Australian donors must agree to be identified.
  • Hire an experienced attorney or advocate in the country you choose for your surrogacy. For example, in Cambodia parental rights are far easier to transfer if your surrogate is unmarried. In the United States, laws vary hugely by state.
  • The availability of surrogacy as a route to parenthood for gay men in seven countries globally is outlined below. Each varies hugely as to the legal protections and rights afforded to surrogates, intended parents and children.

    The United States

    Laws in relation to surrogacy vary hugely from state to state. Approximately 19 states have laws or statutes recognizing compensated (commercial) surrogacy. Another ten have laws recognizing uncompensated (altruistic) surrogacy.

    There are many small and large surrogacy agencies across at least 13 U.S. states that specialize in surrogate recruitment, matching and management. Some of these agencies also offer egg or sperm donors. The experience level of such operators varies widely. Some are ex-surrogates who start their own agency from home; others are multi-state organizations with dozens of staff members and decades of experience. Costs can vary significantly from state to state, so do your homework.

    Some intended U.S. parents can save considerable amounts where they are prepared to put the time and energy into finding a surrogate privately – either through friends and family or via community-based surrogate forums. The problem is, such DIY methods often skip psychological matching and screening processes designed to minimize the chance of later problems.

    U.S. surrogacy options for non-U.S. citizens are plentiful, with many clinics more than willing to meet the needs of offshore clients. Surrogacy agencies in California, Boston, Minnesota and Las Vegas in particular have been assisting foreign parents for many years. A significant number of American IVF clinics allow HIV-positive intended parents. (More information for HIV-positive men wishing to become biological dads can be found in this Gays With Kids article.) What makes the U.S. attractive to foreigners? Legal protections, easy transfer of parentage, and automatic U.S. citizenship for a child born on American soil. On the downside: the high costs of medical care and health insurance, especially if you need to insure a surrogate carrying twins. (As a result, many foreigners forgo insurance entirely and simply hope for the best.) The U.S. is particularly popular with local gay couples as well as with gay couples from Australia, the United Kingdom and mainland Europe.

    Canada

    Canada's laws don't allow surrogates to be paid for carrying a child; only out-of-pocket expenses can be covered. This form of surrogacy called altruistic surrogacy is a model that is also used in Australia and Great Britain. For-profit surrogacy agencies are forbidden. Nonetheless, there are a number of surrogacy facilitators in Canada who work within or around the law. As always be sure to research an agency or individual facilitator before signing on. Canada can be a more cost-effective option than surrogacy in the United States, and many American and British gay men have created families with Canadian surrogates.

    United Kingdom

    Uncompensated (altruistic) surrogacy is accessible to gay couples, including legal transfer of parentage if you are a U.K. citizen and are domiciled in the U.K., Channel Islands or Isle of Man. Compensation of up to £15,000 (approximately US $23,5000) is allowed by the courts, making the UK effectively a commercial system for many. The U.K. provides a lightly regulated process, requiring surrogates and intended parents do little by way of mandatory preparation prior to progressing. Problems include: For-profit surrogacy agencies are illegal so you need to manage the surrogate relationship entirely; paid advertising for surrogates is illegal; and there is no legal protection for intended parents. However, parental orders are available post birth, which transfers full parental status and responsibility from the surrogate to the intended parent.

    Mexico

    As the costs of agencies, attorneys, hospital care and health insurance in the U.S. continue to rise, many IPs are turning to overseas options to fulfill their dreams. Mexico has been allowing uncompensated surrogacy to locals in the state of Tabasco for over a decade; however, after the closing of options for gay men in Southeast Asia, many offshore operators have moved to exploit loopholes that allow surrogacy for foreigners, particularly gay men.

    Mexico's advantages are its affordable medical and legal processes as well as arrangements with Californian IVF clinics to create and implant embryos. (Shipping frozen embryos from abroad for implantation in Mexico is illegal.) In the last 15 months, scores of singles and couples have had children via Mexico. Children born via surrogacy to foreigners are eligible for both a Mexican passport and a passport of their intended parents' home country.

    Like the U.S., laws differ by state and only in the Mexican state of Tabasco is uncompensated surrogacy legal. However, Tabasco's capital Villahermosa has little access to egg donors. Tijuana and Mexico City on the other hand have good access to egg donors, highly experienced IVF physicians and no laws preventing embryo transfer to a surrogate. Surrogates relocate to Tabasco at about the seven-month mark in their pregnancy. There is a shortage of dependable Mexican lawyers in this area.

    Tabasco law protects the rights of intended parents. A gestational surrogate cannot change her mind post birth, as long as she was of sound mind when she signed the gestational agreement. Mexico is a signatory to the 1993 Hague Convention designed to protect children in respect to inter-country adoption and this seems to be delaying granting Mexican passports for children through surrogacy, particularly where a same-sex couple or citizens of a country outlawing surrogacy are involved. Children born via surrogacy are supposed to exit Mexico on a Mexican passport, though given the delays, impatient parents are finding ways to exit using passports of their own country.

    Average total costs for surrogacy in Mexico (using all local resources) range from US $35,000 to US $55,000. (Travel costs are additional.) Mexico accepts gay clients from any country and already is seeing gay singles and couples from the United States, Australia, Europe, Canada and the United Kingdom. The Mexican government is expected to make changes to its relevant laws towards the end of 2015, although it remains unclear whether these changes will open up or restrict surrogacy for foreigners.

    Nepal

    With excellent medical expertise and plentiful surrogates, India had been the affordable destination of choice until restrictive surrogacy visas three years ago banned access to gay singles and couples. As India closed to the gay market, enterprising facilitators from India, Thailand, the United States and Europe rapidly filled the unmet need by opening in Thailand, working with the handful of Thai IVF specialists who would cooperate. Despite a lack of Thai laws governing surrogacy and a birth certificate that retained the surrogate as the legal mother, hundreds of gay couples proceeded. After a little over two years, Thailand too closed its doors to surrogacy not just to gay men, but all foreigners. The frozen embryos of hundreds of gay singles and couples from around the globe face an uncertain future.

    In early 2014, Nepal first appeared as a destination for surrogacy with births to gay men from January; these first surrogates had embryos transferred in India. Experienced Indian clinics have been quick to set up in Kathmandu, the capital of Nepal. Gay Israelis formed the vanguard of intended parents using Nepal. To date over 150 babies have been born to foreigners via surrogacy in Nepal. Despite the recent earthquake, over a dozen facilitators from the United States, Israel, Europe and India now offer surrogacy in Nepal.

    It's important to be aware that only non-Nepalese women can be surrogates; thus far all surrogates have come from India.

    In late August 2015, the Supreme Court of Nepal put a stay on all new embryo transfers for surrogacy, subject to the findings of an enquiry as to why the Nepali government had authorised surrogacy in the absence of relevant law. While it seems likely that Nepal will ultimately pass laws legalising surrogacy, in the interim, there is an open-ended freeze on new arrangements.

    In regard to exit post birth, the American embassy has to date posed few barriers. (DNA testing is now mandatory; already there has been one DNA mis-match.) The Israeli government has been highly supportive of its citizens pursuing surrogacy abroad with exit times of one to two weeks post birth. Australia has taken a much tougher approach to citizenship approval, insisting on interviewing surrogates and checking IDs thoroughly. Exit times have been up to six weeks.

    Cambodia

    In September 2014 neighboring Cambodia opened its first IVF clinic – a state-of-the-art center housing foreign specialists. However, Cambodia has no laws protecting the rights of surrogates or intended parents. When Thailand outlawed surrogacy for all foreigners, the frozen embryos of hundreds of gay singles and couples in Bangkok faced an uncertain future. Many of these precious embryos are now being transferred to Cambodia for surrogacy.

    When I visited in June 2015, already two surrogacy agencies were operational in the Cambodian capital Phnom Penh, with more on the way. The new Royal Phnom Penh Hospital, built for foreigners and with foreign specialists, has been flagged as a preferred birth hospital by some facilitators.

    Surrogacy agencies are painstakingly recruiting local surrogates via word-of-mouth, as advertising is not permitted. In a country where IVF – not to mention surrogacy – is a completely unfamiliar concept, recruitment is slow. It is Chinese intended parents who have been the first to explore surrogacy in this new environment.

    Australia

    In all Australian states except South Australia and Western Australia, uncompensated (altruistic) surrogacy is accessible to gay couples, including legal transfer of parentage. These states provide a highly regulated process, requiring surrogate and intended parent counseling, legal advice and, usually, medical ethics approval prior to progressing. However, there are major problems with regulated Australian surrogacy: Surrogacy agencies are illegal so you need to manage the matching and surrogate relationship entirely; paid advertising for surrogates is illegal; there is a shortage of willing surrogates; only out-of-pocket surrogate expenses can be compensated; and there is no legal protection for intended parents. As a result, most gay Australians pursue surrogacy offshore. However, arguments for policy change to allow compensated surrogacy are gaining political traction.

    The quickly changing global landscape highlights the need for intended parents to be well informed and aware of the risks and how to minimize them in their journeys to create a family. Detailed resources are available here.

    At Families Through Surrogacy's San Francisco conference on September 26-27, 2015, intended patents will hear from a range of parents and professionals on the pros and cons of these diverse pathways to parenthood.

    * In traditional surrogacy, the surrogate's own egg is fertilized using the sperm of the intended father or another sperm donor. In other words, the surrogate is also the egg donor. The surrogate then carries the child to term. In traditional surrogacy, the surrogate is the biological mother of the child. In gestational surrogacy, the surrogate's egg is not used. An embryo is created outside of the body through in vitro fertilization. The egg and sperm may come from the intended parents or from egg and/or sperm donors, depending on circumstances. Once a viable embryo is produced, the embryo is implanted in the surrogate's uterus, and the surrogate carries the child to term. In gestational surrogacy, the surrogate has no biological relationship to the child. Gay men usually choose gestational surrogacy rather than traditional surrogacy as their path to fatherhood.



    Show Comments ()
    Children's Books

    New LGBTQ-Inclusive Children's Book Asks: What Makes a Family?

    A new children's book by Seamus Kirst follows a young girl's journey of emotional discovery after she is asked which of her two dads is her "real dad."

    Editor's note: This is a guest post from Seamus Kirst, author of the new LGBTQ-inclusive children's book "Papa, Daddy, Riley."

    Throughout my life, I have discovered that reading provides an almost miraculous way of changing the way I think.

    There is no medium that better offers insight into the perceptions, feelings and humanity of someone who is different from us. Through reading we become empathetic. Through reading we evolve. I have often emerged from reading a book, and felt like I was changed. In that, even in this digital age, I know I am not alone.

    As children, reading shapes how we see the world. The characters, places, and stories we come to love in our books inform us as to what life might offer us as we grow up, and our world begins to expand beyond our own backyards.

    Keep reading... Show less
    Gay Dad Photo Essays

    Interested in Foster Care? These Amazing Dads Have Some Advice

    As National Foster Care Month comes to a close, we rounded up some amazing examples of gay men serving as foster care dads, helping provide kids with a bright future.

    Every May in the United States, we celebrate National Foster Care Month. With over 437,000 children and youth in foster care, it's our honor to take a look at some of the awesome dads in our community who are opening their hearts and their homes, and providing these kids with a bright future.

    Thinking about becoming a foster parent? Check out these resources here, and visit AdoptUSKids.

    Meet the Foster Dads!

    Keep reading... Show less
    Transracial Families Series

    This Transracial Family Relies on a 'Support Group' of African American Women

    Puerto Rican dads Ferdinand and Manuel are raising a daughter of Jamaican descent — and love to find ways to celebrate their family's diversity

    Our second feature in our transracial family series. Read the first one here.

    Ferdinand Ortiz, 39, and his husband Manuel Gonzalez, 38, have been together for 7 years. In 2017, they became foster dads when they brought their daughter, Mia Valentina, home from the hospital. She was just three days old at the time. On December 13, 2018, her adoption was finalized.

    Mia is of Jamaican and African American heritage, and her dads are both Puerto Rican. When Manuel and Ferdinand began their parenting journey through the foster care system, they received specific training on how to be the parents of a child whose race and culture was different from their own. "We learned that it's important to celebrate our child's culture and surround ourselves with people who can help her be proud of her culture." However, as helpful as this training was, the dads agreed that it would've been beneficial to hear from other transracial families and the type of challenges that they faced.

    Keep reading... Show less
    Personal Essays by Gay Dads

    How the Shut Down Opened Me Up to Being a Better Dad

    David Blacker's dad used to tell him to 'stop and smell the roses' — the shut down has led him to finally take the advice

    "Stop and smell the roses." It was the thing my dad always said to me when I was growing up. But like many know-it-all kids, I didn't listen. I was determined to keep my eye on the prize. Whether it was getting good grades in school, getting my work published, scoring the next big promotion, buying a house or starting a family. For me, there was no such thing as resting on my laurels. It has always been about what's next and mapping out the exact course of action to get me there.

    Then Covid.

    Ten weeks ago, I — along with the rest of the world — was ordered to shelter-in-place... to stop thinking about what's next, and instead, focus on the here and the now. In many ways, the shut down made me shut off everything I thought I knew about being content and living a productive life. And so, for the first time in my 41 years, I have literally been forced to stop and smell the roses. The question is, would I like the way they smell?

    Keep reading... Show less
    Transracial Families Series

    How This Transracial Family Creates a 'Safe Space' to Talk About Their Differences

    Kevin and David know they can never understand what it's like growing up as a young black girl — but they strive to create a 'safe space' for their daughters to talk about the experience

    Editor's Note: This is the first in a series of ongoing posts exploring issues related to transracial families headed by gay, bi and trans men. Interested in being featured as part of the series? Email us at dads@gayswithkids.com

    Is adopting a child whose race and culture is different from your own something that us queer dads need to talk about? Share our experiences? Learn from others? We've been hearing from our community, and the answer has been a resounding, "yes."

    With over one-fifth (21.4%) of same-sex couples raising adopted children in the United States today (compared to 3% of different-sex couples), it's highly likely, at the very least, that those families are transcultural. According to April Dinwoodie, Chief Executive of The Donaldson Adoption Institute, Inc., all adoptive families are transcultural. "All, in my opinion, adoptions are transcultural because there are no two families' culture that is exactly the same, even if you went as far as to get very specific about the family of origin and the family of experience and almost make it cookie-cutter … no two families operate the same."

    Keep reading... Show less
    Gay Dad Life

    Movie Night: My Favorite Family Tradition

    As his sons have gotten older, the movies have morphed away from cartoons and towards things blowing up — but movie night remains his favorite family tradition.

    Editor's Note: This is the next in a series of excerpts from Joseph Sadusky's new book, Magic Lessons: Celebratory and Cautionary Tales about Life as a (Single, Gay, Transracially Adoptive) Dad. The book contains many stories about his life as a dad, as well as lessons learned, and we're excited to share several excerpts from the the book over the course of the next few months. Read previous installments here!

    Of all of our traditions and rituals, probably the most consistent and longest-lasting one was movie night. Sure, we read the heck out of Harry Potter. But our capacity for watching Harry Potter? We're talking Quidditch World Cup here, folks.

    In its early version, movie night looked like this: During the week, I would order a movie and a cartoon from Netflix—back when "Netflix" meant "mail." On Saturday night—and I mean, faithfully, every Saturday night—we would order a pepperoni pizza (which Mark faithfully took the meat off of—I'll get to food later) for delivery and then sit and watch our cartoon and movies while eating. The kids had a say in the movie, but I got to pick the cartoon. They watched enough of their own cartoons on the regular, and besides, this gave me a great opportunity to introduce them to the wonders of Rocky and Bullwinkle and Josie and the Pussycats.


    Keep reading... Show less
    Gay Dad Life

    Happy Mother's Day From Gays With Kids!

    To all of the women who have supported the journey of gay, bi and trans men towards fatherhood — thank you, and happy Mother's Day

    Mother's Day can be complicated holiday for many gay, bi and trans dads and their kids. Choosing how, when — or even if — to celebrate the day is a uniquely personal decision. But no matter how we've become dads, women have helped us achieve our dreams of fatherhood. And for that reason, we've loved celebrating all of the women who have supported our journeys to fatherhood, in ways big and small, over the years. Check out some of our favorite photos, essays, articles and more below!


    Keep reading... Show less

    Fatherhood, the gay way

    Get the latest from Gays With Kids delivered to your inbox!

    Follow Gays With Kids

    Powered by RebelMouse